DIY vs. Pro with Yellow Background

DIY vs. Pro: When to Call a Locksmith and the Tools They Bring

Have you ever been staring at a locked door with the keys on the wrong side? Even the best of us experience it. This guide explores both of your options—repairing the lock on your own or hiring a locksmith. This tool enables you to recover your domain, regardless of whether you like the challenge of doing repairs yourself or would rather leave it to the professionals. We will go over the realm of lockpicking methods, professional tools, and the benefits of hiring a locksmith. Now that you have inhaled deeply, let us get you back inside!

Table of Contents

Key Takeaways

DIY Lockpicking: Requires specific skills, knowledge, and tools. Not suitable for high-security locks or emergencies. Improper attempts can damage the lock.

Benefits of a Locksmith: Expertise in various lock types, advanced tools, efficient service, and peace of mind.

Call a Locksmith: Broken key extraction, jammed or damaged locks (repair options before replacement), and high-security systems.

Locksmith’s Expertise:  Advanced techniques for repairs (impressioning, de-pinning), proper lubrication, and knowledge of high-security systems.

Choosing a Locksmith: Research online reviews, look for certifications and save their contact information in advance.

Be Prepared: Having a reliable locksmith’s contact info readily available can save you time and stress in an emergency.

DIY Lockpicking: Limitations and Risks

A. Skills and Knowledge Required

Lockpicking necessitates a particular aptitude and knowledge base. Proficiency in various lock mechanisms, proper picking techniques, and the finesse to manipulate tools effectively are all essential for achieving success.  Amateurs frequently lack this expertise, which can lead to frustration and potentially damage the lock.

Locks come in many shapes and sizes, but their core function relies on a complex interplay of components. Here’s a peek inside:

  • Pins and Wafers: These tiny barriers inside the lock prevent the cylinder from turning unless aligned correctly. The key’s ridges and grooves correspond to the specific arrangement these pins need to fall into for the lock to open.
  • Shear Lines: These are strategically placed points within the pins that need to be perfectly aligned by the key to allow them to move freely.
  • Driver Pins: These are spring-loaded pins pushed upwards by the key. When aligned correctly, they create a channel that allows the cylinder to rotate.
  • Security Wards: These are maze-like formations within the lock that prevent anything other than the correctly shaped key from reaching the pins.

The complexity increases with additional features like:

  • Multiple Pin Stacks: More rows of pins exponentially increase the number of possible combinations.
  • Sidebars: These are additional components that introduce new conditions for the lock to open.
  • Magnetic or Electronic Components: High-security locks may incorporate these for even more intricate unlocking mechanisms.

Lock-picking exploits vulnerabilities in the mechanism to manipulate the pins and wafers without a key. Here’s how lock pickers navigate this intricate dance:

  • Picking Tools: These specialized tools come in various shapes and sizes, like picks (to manipulate pins) and tension wrenches (to apply turning pressure).
  • Feeling the Pins: Pickers develop a finesse to sense the binding pins (those preventing rotation) and use the pick to move them into the correct position.
  • Bypassing Security Measures: Experienced pickers may use techniques to navigate warding or exploit tolerances within the mechanism.

However, picking difficulty varies depending on the lock type:

  • Simpler pin tumbler locks might be susceptible to manipulation with basic tools and practice.
  • High-security locks with complex pin arrangements, sidebar mechanisms, or electronic components may be nearly impossible to pick without specialized knowledge and equipment.

Important Note: Lock picking is a skill best left to professionals.  Tampering with locks can be illegal and damage the mechanism.

Using improper tools or methods to open a lock can damage it in several ways:

  • Broken pins: The pins inside a lock are delicate. Using the wrong size or type of tool to pick them can bend or break them, rendering the lock unusable.
  • Scratched or scraped exterior: Forcing a tool into the lock can scratch or scrape the exterior, making it easier to tamper with in the future.
  • Damaged internal mechanism: Prying, hammering, or using excessive force can damage the internal mechanisms of the lock, like the springs or housing. This can make it difficult or impossible to open even with the correct key.
  • stripped threads: If you use the wrong key or force a key that doesn’t quite fit, you can strip the threads in the lock cylinder, making it impossible to use any key at all.

In short, improper methods are more likely to break the lock than open it. You’ll end up needing a locksmith and potentially a whole new lock installation.

B. Limited Toolset for DIY

While lock-picking tools can be purchased, DIY enthusiasts may not have access to the specialized tools required to conquer certain high-security locks. Without the appropriate tools, overcoming these locks becomes nearly impossible, rendering the DIY approach ineffective.

Lock-picking relies on two main tools:

  • Tension wrenches: These apply constant turning pressure mimicking a key. Different wrenches fit various lock types.
  • Picks:  These come in various shapes for manipulating the pins inside the lock. Common types include triangle picks for versatility and hook picks for individual pin control.


  • Skill: Lock picking requires practice and finesse. Picks are not magic lock openers.
  • Lock type: While some picks are versatile, some locks require specific tools. A pick designed for pin tumbler locks won’t work on a wafer lock.
  • Complexity: Advanced locks may have multiple security features needing specialized tools beyond basic picks and wrenches.

Obtaining advanced tools:  

Getting these specialized picks can be difficult. Locksmith suppliers often require proof of licensure to ensure these tools aren’t used for illegal purposes.


C. Time is of the Essence

You spend hours hunched over YouTube tutorials, squinting at blurry phone screens trying to decipher what that guy’s doing with that weird metal rake. You rummage through your toolbox, desperately searching for anything vaguely pick-shaped – a paperclip just doesn’t feel right. The lock stares back at you, unyielding. Minutes crawl by, punctuated by the disheartening clicks and groans of metal against metal. Frustration mounts like a steam engine. “Just one little click,” you mutter, but the lock remains stubbornly silent.

There’s that nagging feeling in the back of your head: all this wasted time. You could have called a locksmith an hour ago, and been enjoying a cup of coffee instead of this self-inflicted torture. The DIY method might seem appealing at first, but the reality is a pit of frustration and wasted minutes that could have been spent productively (or at least relaxing!).

In emergencies where time is critical, lockpicking may not be the most efficient course of action. A seasoned locksmith can typically open a lock much faster than someone attempting to pick it up for the first time. Furthermore, fumbling with tools during a stressful situation can heighten the risk of damaging the lock or injuring oneself.

Benefits of Calling a Locksmith

A. Expertise and Experience

Locksmiths are like security doctors for your locks and keys. They’ve been trained on different lock designs, from your front door to your car ignition, and they’ve seen all sorts of situations where people get locked out or need their keys replaced. This means they can quickly figure out what’s wrong with your lock and the best way to fix it, whether it’s replacing the whole thing, making a new key, or just getting you back inside without damaging anything.

B. Advanced Tools for Any Lock

Locksmiths aren’t just about lockpicks! They wield a comprehensive arsenal of tools, from the classic to the cutting edge. This includes:

  • Specialized Picks: Beyond the standard picks, they have tools like tubular lock picks for specific lock types and Lishi car picks designed for modern vehicles.
  • Electronic Tools: Laser key cutters and key duplicators handle key creation and replication with precision.

But their expertise goes beyond tools. Locksmiths can:

  • Rekey Locks: They can modify existing locks to work with new keys, saving you the hassle of replacing the entire lock.
  • Extract Broken Keys: Broken keys are no match for their extractors, saving you from a potentially frustrating situation.
  • Handle High-Security Systems: They’re equipped to deal with complex security systems, keeping your valuables protected.

C. Efficiency and Peace of Mind

I was locked out in a complete panic! But within minutes of calling a locksmith, they were at my door. It was incredibly fast. The locksmith was a total professional, calmly assessing the situation and getting to work right away.  They had the tools and expertise to deal with my lock issue quickly and effectively.  In no time at all, I was back inside.  Having a skilled professional handle everything gave me immense peace of mind. I knew I wasn’t going to damage the door or lock myself, and they got me back in my house faster than I could have ever hoped for.

Examples of When to Call a Locksmith

A. Broken Key Extraction

A broken key lodged in a lock can be a stressful situation. While it might be tempting to yank it out with brute force, this can easily damage the lock mechanism, leading to a costlier fix. Thankfully, there’s a more delicate approach that utilizes specialized tools to remove the broken piece without harming the lock.

Here’s why this process requires special tools and a careful touch:

  1. Internal Mechanism: Locks have intricate mechanisms with springs and pins. Jamming a screwdriver or forcing the broken key can misalign these components, rendering the lock inoperable.
  2. Broken Key Shape: The broken piece might not have a convenient grip for your fingers. Specialized tools are designed to fit into grooves or grab hold of specific areas of the key for better control.
  3. Precision Matters: Tiny movements with the right tools can extract the broken key without further damaging it or the lock.

Here are some specialized tools commonly used for broken key extraction:

  • Key Extractor: This comes in two main types:
    • Spiral Flute Extractor: A thin, flexible metal rod with a spiraling thread. It inserts into the lock and twists, grabbing the broken key fragment as it’s withdrawn.
    • Hook-and-Pick Extractor: A small tool with a hooked end that can latch onto the broken key’s teeth or ridges for better-pulling force.
  • Tweezers or Needle-Nose Pliers: If a small portion of the key protrudes from the lock, these tools can provide a good grip for gentle extraction.

Remember: It’s crucial to choose the right tool for the specific break and lock type.  If you’re unsure or uncomfortable with the process, calling a professional locksmith is always the safest option. They have the expertise and advanced tools to handle the situation efficiently and minimize damage.

B. Jammed or Damaged Locks

Replacing a lock can be expensive and time-consuming. Luckily, skilled locksmiths have a toolbox of advanced techniques to diagnose and address jammed or damaged locks before resorting to a full replacement. Here are some examples:

  • Impressioning: This involves creating a new key based on the marks left on the lock by a damaged or jammed key. A locksmith uses specialized tools to take an “impression” of the internal mechanism and then crafts a key that can operate the lock.
  • De-pinning and Re-pinning: This technique involves disassembling the lock and manipulating the internal pins to bypass the jam or damage.  A skilled locksmith can identify worn or misaligned pins and replace them, effectively creating a new lock combination without needing a whole new unit.
  • Lock Disassembly and Cleaning: Sometimes, a simple jam can be caused by dirt, debris, or corrosion. A locksmith can carefully disassemble the lock, clean the internal components, and reassemble it, restoring functionality without needing a replacement.
  • Power Tools (Controlled):  In some cases, electric drills or rotary tools might be used for very specific purposes. This could involve carefully drilling out a broken key fragment or removing a damaged section of the lock housing to access the internal mechanism for repair. However,  due to the risk of further damage, this is a delicate process only attempted by experienced professionals.
  • Advanced Lubrication:  While basic lubricants like WD-40 are readily available, professional locksmiths have access to specialized lubricants designed for specific lock mechanisms. These lubricants can reduce friction, improve pin movement, and potentially resolve minor jams without needing replacement.

Important Note:  While these techniques can be effective, it’s crucial to remember that attempting lock repairs yourself, especially with advanced tools, can be risky.  Improper handling can cause further damage and render the lock unusable. It’s always best to call a qualified locksmith who can assess the situation and determine the most appropriate course of action.

C. High-Security Systems

High-security systems are designed to safeguard sensitive information, assets, or areas against sophisticated threats. Unlike home security systems, they operate on a whole different level, demanding intricate setups and specialized expertise.

Complexity: A Multi-Layered Challenge

  • Integrated Systems: High-security systems aren’t isolated units. They’re a complex web of interconnected components – alarms, access control systems, CCTV, intrusion detection – working in unison. Even a minor glitch in one element can disrupt the entire security apparatus.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication: Gone are the days of simple passwords. High-security systems often rely on multi-factor authentication, requiring a combination of credentials like keycards, biometrics (fingerprint, iris scan), and tokens for access. This layered approach strengthens defense against unauthorized entry.
  • Encryption Everywhere:  Sensitive data is shielded using robust encryption techniques. This scrambles information into an unreadable format, making it impossible for intruders to decipher even if they breach the system.
  • Network Security: High-security systems often operate on dedicated, isolated networks to minimize vulnerabilities from external intrusions. Firewalls and constant monitoring further enhance their resilience.

Specialized Skills:  Unveiling the Magic Behind the Machine

The complexity of high-security systems necessitates specialized tools and training for their installation, maintenance, and operation.

  • Security System Design and Integration:  Planning a high-security system requires in-depth knowledge of security threats, risk assessment, and the ability to integrate various components seamlessly.  These specialists create a customized security plan that addresses the client’s specific needs.
  • Installation and Configuration:  Installing these intricate systems demands expertise. Trained technicians ensure proper placement of sensors, cameras, and access control points, adhering to strict protocols to maintain system integrity.
  • Monitoring and Response:  Trained security personnel monitor the system 24/7, analyzing alerts and taking appropriate action in case of breaches. They might involve contacting law enforcement, deploying security personnel, or initiating pre-defined lockdown procedures.
  • Penetration Testing:  Ethical hackers, using specialized tools, simulate real-world attacks to identify and address weaknesses in the security system before malicious actors exploit them.


In conclusion, for situations beyond a simple misplaced key, a locksmith is the answer.  They offer the advantage of rapid response, especially in emergencies, along with the expertise to handle intricate lock issues without damaging your property.  Their professional service ensures a safe and secure solution.

Call to Action

Before you find yourself in a lockout jam, take some proactive steps:

Save a Locksmith’s Contact Information!

Being prepared is key. Program the contact details of a reputable locksmith, like Jones and Sons Locksmith at (614) 915-0609, into your phone.  That way, you’ll have immediate access to help in an emergency. With Jones and Sons Locksmith’s fast response and expertise, you’ll be back inside your home or car in no time, without any unnecessary stress or damage.

Recommended Articles